15 Best Pizza Topping Combos for Homemade Pizza

It’s perfectly fine you are no more into classic pizza flavors. Yes, it happens when your taste buds don’t enjoy the classic Fajita, supreme, or deluxe pizza anymore. So, right when you face these circumstances, it’s high time you should try different pizza topping ideas and combos for your homemade pizza to relive the dying pizza experience.

Best Pizza Topping Combos for Homemade Pizza

However, if you are clueless about what things to put on a pizza, let’s observe my favorite and best pizza topping combos for daily or weekend pizza fiesta. So let’s straight jump onto these;

15 Best Pizza Topping Combos for Homemade Pizza

While there are 1000s of fancy pizza toppings ideas out there, I have arranged my list according to pizza styles. I have arranged things like;

  • Authentic Italian Pizza Style
  • Classic American Style
  • Versatile Asian Style

To be honest, some of the pizza flavor combos are going to be fancy and little complex due to irregular kitchen ingredients. But you can still make pizzas with different variations. Let’s start;

Authentic Italian Pizza Style

1. Margherita Pizza – Most Popular Pizza Topping combination

Margherita Pizza
  • Complexity: Easy
  • Variation: Add sliced tomatoes or a balsamic drizzle for a gourmet touch.
  • Sauce Combo: Can pair with a garlic sauce or pesto for a unique flavor profile.

When you want to remain classic but try to add a different flavor, it’s the Margherita pizza. Well, far away from fancy pizza toppings, the classic tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil leaves, and a finishing drizzle of extra virgin olive oil are the main course here. But then, don’t let its simplicity fool you; the flavors are divine.

I often whip these homemade pizza toppings when I direly feel a lack of authentic Italian flavor in my blood. And for the versatility part, I sometimes add some sliced tomatoes or even swap the tomato sauce with a flavorful garlic sauce or a vibrant pesto. Perfect for those who appreciate the classic yet creative pizza idea to taste the uncomplicated flavor of Italy.

PROS

  • Easy and simple to prepare with minimal ingredients
  • It’s easily be customized with added toppings or different sauces

CONS

  • Might be too simple for some; who prefer more complex taste and toppings
  • Using a lower-quality cheese might impact the overall taste – Highly dependent on Cheese Quality

2. Capricciosa Pizza – For Tangy and Salty Lovers

Capricciosa Pizza
  • Complexity: Medium
  • Variation: Swap ham for prosciutto or add anchovies for a salty kick.
  • Sauce Combo: Olive oil and garlic sauce can add a depth of flavor.

With tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham, mushrooms, artichokes, and black olives, it’s surely a delicious pizza flavor combo that never fails to delight. That said, I usually prepare this for my friends during our pizza nights, and it’s never been less than a blockbuster.

For more pizza topping ideas, you can swap the ham for prosciutto or add anchovies for that extra salty kick. And when you are a multi-flavored fan, garlic-infused olive oil or sauce can give it a beautiful depth of flavor that truly satisfies the palate.

PROS

  • Diverse and satisfying range of flavors and textures
  • Can easily be customized, swapping in or out the ingredients is a breeze

CONS

  • Diversity of toppings might be overwhelming for some – Getting it?
  • Assembling a Capricciosa pizza can take more time and effort – Not for lazy chefs

3. Quattro Formaggi Pizza – A Cheese Lover’s Dream

Quattro Formaggi Pizza
  • Complexity: Easy
  • Variation: Experiment with different cheese blends, or add figs for a sweet twist.
  • Sauce Combo: Try a white garlic sauce instead of traditional tomato.

The symphony of mozzarella, gorgonzola, parmesan, and fontina cheese is always a delight, and these sort of toppings for pizza at home makes a Quattro Formaggi pizza. To be honest, it’s my comfort food after a long day, and it’s always a winner for cheese lovers. When I say Cheese lovers, I sometimes experiment with different cheeses, making a new pizza flavor combo with smoky provolone or creamy camembert.

All in all, you can also make it sweet and give it a savory twist. Try adding figs. My God, they pair beautifully with the cheese. And if you’re not in the mood for tomato sauce, white garlic sauce can be served as a salty and less pungent alternative.

PROS

  • Perfect for cheese lovers who appreciate a wide array of flavors and textures
  • Offers a lot of room for customization and experimentation

CONS

  • Pizza quite rich and heavy, which might not appeal to everyone
  • Again, highly dependent on cheese quality

4. Prosciutto e Funghi Pizza – A Treat for Intense Flavor Lovers

Prosciutto e Funghi Pizza
  • Complexity: Medium
  • Variation: Add fresh arugula after baking for a fresh twist.
  • Sauce Combo: A truffle sauce can add a gourmet touch.

Those indulgent pizza nights, a prosciutto e Funghi Pizza, and me; a perfect union. This is because rich tomato sauce, melted mozzarella, salty prosciutto crudo, and earthy mushrooms make it one of the best pizza topping combos. Though it has some fancy ingredients, it’s always a crowd-pleaser at gatherings.

To turn this creative pizza idea into more fun, a handful of fresh arugula after baking works like a charm. Its peppery flavor and fresh crunch perfectly balance the richness of the prosciutto and mushrooms. And if you want to turn out to be more fancy, try it with a truffle sauce. It gives the pizza flavor a whole new dimension.

PROS

  • Luxurious treat that’s perfect for indulgent evenings
  • Fresh arugula and the option to use truffle sauce provide a balance of flavors

CONS

  • Fancy Ingredients may not readily available in all areas like Prosciutto or truffle sauce
  • Strong flavors might not appeal to all

5. Salsiccia e Friarielli Pizza – Bring it on for Spice Lovers

Salsiccia e Friarielli Pizza
  • Complexity: Hard
  • Variation: Substitute friarielli with broccolini if you can’t find the Italian variant.
  • Sauce Combo: A spicy arrabbiata sauce gives it an extra kick.

Again, a much more fancy yet best pizza topping combination when it comes to authentic Italian Cuisine. With that being said, the Salsiccia e Friarielli pizza is a taste of Naples in every bite. The arrangement of tomato sauce, mozzarella, Italian sausage, and friarielli, the fusion of intense flavors, tastes the best. It’s my go-to when my “Experimentation” genes get activated.

But as Friarielli is also a fancy ingredient, you can substitute it with broccolini in case of an Italian variant absence, and it works just as great. Moreover, replicating the traditional tomato sauce with a spicy arrabbiata sauce brings more fun for spice lovers. It adds an exciting kick that pairs beautifully with the robust flavors of the sausage and friarielli.

PROS

  • Combination of Italian sausage and friarielli (or broccolini) creates a distinct, interesting taste
  • Spicy arrabbiata sauce brings an exciting dimension of heat and spice

CONS

  • Specialized Ingredients may not likely to be readily available in all areas
  • Not for those who prefer milder flavors or have a low tolerance for spiciness

American Style Pizza Topping Ideas and Combos:

1. BBQ Chicken Pizza: For Typical BBQ Lovers

BBQ Chicken Pizza
  • Complexity: Easy
  • Variations: Substitute chicken with pork or tofu, add bell peppers or olives.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Works well with spicy BBQ sauce or even a honey mustard sauce.

When you want to remain simple yet flavorful, it’s a showstopper. Not a very fancy pizza flavor combo, but it’s my usual pick when I want to get slightly sidelined from classic pizza flavors. The pizza topping combination of barbecue sauce, mozzarella, grilled chicken, red onion, and cilantro gives a wonderful sweet and tangy flavor that’s just irresistible for BBQ lovers like me. Want to activate your taste buds a little more? Replace the barbecue sauce with a spicy BBQ variant so the contrast of flavors should always be a hit.

PROS

  • Delightful deviation from classic pizza flavors with a sweet and tangy profile
  • Easy option for flavor experimentation

CONS

  • Finding the balance between sweet and tangy flavors can be tricky

2. Hawaiian Pizza: For Users Who Just Need a “Pizza” At Any Cost

Hawaiian Pizza
  • Complexity: Easy
  • Variations: Swap ham for Canadian bacon or bacon bits. Use BBQ sauce instead of tomato sauce.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Pairs well with tangy pineapple sauce or sweet chili sauce.

Yeah, Yeah I know Hawaiian pizza has a bit controversial fan base, but my love for the combination of sweet pineapple and salty ham on a mozzarella and tomato base never fades away. This pizza topping combo is my first ever thought on a lazy Sunday when I crave something different. But if you don’t like any ingredient like classic tomato sauce, let it swap with BBQ sauce, and it becomes more delightful.

PROS

  • Offers a fantastic sweet and salty balance
  • Fun and exotic choice for those who want to move away from traditional pizza toppings

CONS

  • Not everyone appreciates the presence of pineapple on a pizza

3. Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Best Meat Pizza Toppings

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
  • Complexity: Medium
  • Variations: Use grilled chicken instead of buffalo chicken, add jalapenos for an extra kick.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Can substitute blue cheese with ranch or add a layer of buffalo hot sauce for extra heat.

Want to try something “gracious” and spicy as your best homemade pizza topping? The base of hot sauce and blue cheese, topped with mozzarella, buffalo chicken, celery, and a drizzle of ranch dressing, is a paradise for spice lovers. When you want “That” extra kick, it’s the perfect shot for those who love a bit of heat.

Making this the best pizza topping combo for spice lovers, I usually try it while adding jalapenos for an even spicier version, and trust me; you would want more. Its taste profile makes your taste buds dance with its spicy, tangy, and creamy profile.

PROS

  • Offers a delightful combination of spicy, tangy, and creamy flavors
  • Perfect choice for spice lovers

CONS

  • Spicy flavor might not suit everyone’s taste
  • Hot sauce and blue cheese base might be overpowering for some.

4. Philly Cheesesteak Pizza: Could be a Wow for Deep Taste Lovers

Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
  • Recipe Complexity: Medium
  • Variations: Use chicken instead of beef, add mushrooms or a hot sauce drizzle for more flavor.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Works well with BBQ sauce, marinara sauce, or even a creamy alfredo sauce.

With the intent of a proper meal, Philly Cheesesteak pizza tastes as good as it sounds. The combo of olive oil and garlic base, provolone cheese, thinly sliced beefsteak, bell peppers, and onions, the long and diversified list of pizza toppings definitely makes it richly flavorful and versatile to play with.

Whenever you are in the mood for a hearty, satisfying meal, this creative pizza idea says you hello. The contrast of flavors and textures is truly wonderful. And while it’s delicious as is, adding mushrooms or a hot sauce drizzle just takes it to the next level.

PROS

  • Offers a hearty and fulfilling meal experience
  • Ample room for creativity and personalization

CONS

  • Might be overwhelming for those who prefer simpler pizza toppings
  • Fancy ingredients make it slightly more complex and time-consuming

5. Bacon and Eggs Pizza: A Delightful Combo for Breakfast

Bacon and Eggs Pizza
  • Complexity: Medium
  • Variations: Add bell peppers, spinach, or swap bacon with sausage or ham.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Tastes great with a spicy tomato sauce or a garlic-infused olive oil base.

It’s an unusual yet satisfying pizza topping combo that starts with a white sauce base, topped with mozzarella, crispy bacon, and a cracked egg on top. For better and more flavorful seasoning, spinach or bell peppers are also good for color and nutrition.

While the yolk adds a creamy richness that complements the crispy, salty bacon beautifully, swapping the white sauce with a spicy tomato will ensure an exciting flavor contrast. This pizza is an explosion of flavors in every bite and the perfect morning indulgence.

PROS

  • Addition of spinach or bell peppers not only provides nutritional benefits
  • Easiest to make in quick time

CONS

  • Might not be to everyone’s liking due to its unconventional topping mix
  • Preparing the egg perfectly can be tricky

Asian Best Pizza Topping Combos:

1. Thai Chicken Pizza: People Looking for Traditional Asian Pizza Flavor

Thai Chicken Pizza
  • Recipe Complexity: Medium
  • Variation: Can substitute peanut sauce with sweet chili sauce for a slightly different flavor.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Soy sauce or sweet chili sauce can be used for additional flavor.

When it comes to fusing different cuisines, like typical Asian with a fusion of Thai, my Thai Chicken pizza is always a hit. With a peanut sauce base, mozzarella, grilled chicken, shredded carrots, red onion, and cilantro – it’s like having Thailand in every bite! I do often, but I always love to swap the peanut sauce with a sweet chili sauce for a bit of a kick.

PROS

  • Offers a unique taste experience.
  • Flexibility enough to allow addition of other veggies.

CONS

  • Peanut sauce may not be easygoing with major audience.
  • Might be a bit complex to prepare at home

2. Peking Duck Pizza: Perfect for Individuals, Preferring Mild Flavor

Peking Duck Pizza
  • Recipe Complexity: Medium,
  • Variation: Can add additional toppings like mushrooms or bell peppers.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Can be served with a side of plum sauce for added flavor.

For users who want to enjoy a more flavorful yet balanced profile, the hoisin sauce, mozzarella, shredded Peking duck, green onions, and cucumber rightly follow your preferences. Just when you need an Asian twist, it’s just delightful.

And when the need for experimentation kicks in, I sometimes add mushrooms or bell peppers – and it works every time! This creative pizza idea, with flexible practicality, is a big hit amongst my adventurous foodie friends who are always game for trying new flavors.

PROS

  • Provides a unique blend of Chinese and Italian cuisine.
  • Versatile

CONS

  • Preparing Peking duck can be a bit complex and time-consuming.
  • Some might find the flavor of hoisin sauce too overpowering.

3. Korean BBQ Pizza: Any BBQ Lovers out there? It’s Calling You!

Korean BBQ Pizza
  • Recipe Complexity: Medium-Hard, requires preparing Korean BBQ beef and kimchi.
  • Variation: Can use pork or chicken instead of beef.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Can be paired with a side of Korean BBQ sauce for an extra kick.

When it comes to my favorite and the best homemade pizza toppings in the BBQ niche, it gets my vote without any question. I am saying this because the spicy, sweet, and tangy gochujang base, coupled with the rich and smoky Korean BBQ beef, tangy kimchi, and nutty sesame seeds, furnish an experience that is surely out of this world.

And if I want to switch it up a little, I substitute the beef with juicy pork or succulent chicken – it’s equally as tasty. If you’re a fan of Korean flavors or just love a good, spicy pizza, this one’s for you!

PROS

  • Incorporates spicy and savory Korean flavors into a pizza.
  • Can substitute the Korean BBQ beef with other proteins like chicken or pork.

CONS

  • Gochujang and kimchi might be hard to find in regular grocery stores.
  • The spiciness might not appeal to everyone.

4. Teriyaki Chicken Pizza: Perfect for Sweet and Savor Lovers

Teriyaki Chicken Pizza
  • Complexity: Easy,
  • Variation: Can add additional veggies like bell peppers or mushrooms.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Can drizzle a bit of sriracha on top for a spicy kick.

When you want to go with chicken and keep it sweet and savory, Teriyaki Chicken Pizza has the best pizza topping combos in the league. The combination of the sweet and sticky teriyaki sauce, creamy mozzarella, juicy teriyaki chicken, tangy pineapple, and sharp red onion is a harmony of flavors on a pizza crust.

And sprinkling some bell peppers or mushrooms on top brings much-needed crisp. Along with a fiery drizzle of sriracha on top is like you just have the spicy kick, taking this pizza flavor combo to a whole new dimension.

PROS

  • Provides delicious contrast with the other ingredients.
  • Flexible for Experimentation.

CONS

  • Pineapple on pizza might not be everyone’s cup of tea.
  • Might be a challenge for some to find the right flavor balance.

5. Spicy Tuna Pizza

Spicy Tuna Pizza
  • Complexity: Medium
  • Variation: Can use salmon instead of tuna.
  • Combo with Different Sauces: Drizzle extra unagi sauce or add a touch of wasabi for a flavor boost.

Out of BBQ and Veg world, Spicy Tuna pizza is something unconventional and the best seafood pizza idea. For pizza enthusiasts who want to keep their Italian tradition alive with a fusion of Japanese touch, this homemade pizza topping idea is the real depiction. With a spicy mayo base, creamy mozzarella, thinly sliced raw tuna, crispy green onions, and a rich drizzle of unagi sauce, it’s like a sushi roll but on a pizza! And don’t worry; tuna can easily be replaced with Salmon. It’s a perfect swap and tastes equally amazing. A little touch of wasabi elegantly opens the gates of spicy notes.

PROS

  • Offers a unique fusion of Italian and Japanese flavors.
  • Can swap out tuna for other types of fish like salmon.

CONS

  • The raw fish topping might not be appealing to everyone.
  • Might be complex for beginners to prepare unagi sauce.

My Best 3 Pizza Topping Combinations As a Mild and BBQ Lover:

Now, I am purely a BBQ and Meat Lover guy, so if you are on the same page and curious enough to know my top 3 toppings for a pizza at home, see below;

My Best 3 Pizza Topping Combinations As a Mild and BBQ Lover
Infographic: My Best 3 Pizza Topping Combinations As a Mild and BBQ Lover
  • BBQ Chicken Pizza (American Style): BBQ and Cheese lover, here is your pizza flavor combo. The reason for this, its foundation is a delicious BBQ sauce base topped with mozzarella, grilled chicken, and red onions, delivering a savory, tangy, and smoky flavor profile.
  • Hawaiian Pizza (American Style): I like it when my taste buds go naughty. This pizza, with its combination of tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham, and pineapple, offers the perfect balance of salty, tangy, and sweet flavors that you’re sure to enjoy.
  • Thai Chicken Pizza (Asian Style): While most Asian pizza topping combos include meat, cheese, and spices, this one has a unique mix of sweet, sour, and slightly spicy flavors. It comes from its peanut sauce base, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken, shredded carrots, red onion, and cilantro toppings. For meat and cheese lovers, it’s a bit exotic but aligns with your taste profile well. Top of Form

The Bottom Line:

So you can find 1000’s of homemade pizza topping ideas on the internet, literally. That’s why I have categorized these 15 pizza topping combos according to regions. So, whether it’s a classic, creative, or fancy pizza topping, you can easily align it with your preferences and mood.  

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *